Forensic AI or Flawed Science? Examining Risk Assessments in Criminal Justice

Abstract

This presentation critically examines the forensic application of AI-driven risk assessments in law enforcement, sentencing, and corrections. It will explore how these tools analyze behavioral patterns, criminal history, and psychology factors to predict offending, while highlighting concerns about bias, reliability, and the limits of algorithmic decision-making. The session will also discuss recent best practices for evaluating AI-based risk models and ensuring responsible use in criminal justice settings.

Date
Event
Location
Online (University of Surrey)

Prof. Melissa Hamilton from the University of Surrey will lead the online journal club session titled “Forensic AI or Flawed Science? Examining Risk Assessments in Criminal Justice” on 20th March 2025, from 16:00 to 17:00. The event will delve into critical evaluations of AI-driven risk assessment tools, exploring their strengths, biases, and implications for criminal justice practices.

Avatar
Elizabeth Williams
Director of Teaching

Elizabeth Williams is the Hub’s Director of Teaching and a Associate Professor at the School of Law.

Avatar
Melissa Hamilton

Dr Melissa Hamilton is a member of the Hub and a Professor at the School of Law.